PSAT Reading Question 434: Answer and Explanation

Question: 434

The surrounding context around Ned's statement in lines 36–37, "Now we . . . do that," suggests that this quote was

• A. an outright deception.
• B. somewhat disingenuous.
• C. given under duress.
• D. motivated by true love.

Correct Answer: B

Explanation:

(B) Lines 36–38 consist of Ned's promise to always be with Alice. Since he later glosses over this commitment to Alice, it is appropriate to infer that he was disingenuous, misleading, or insincere. Choice (A) is an extreme that is ultimately unfair to Ned, who attempts, somewhat halfheartedly, to keep the love alive through his letters. Choice (C) indicates that he committed himself to Alice under great pressure or force, which is untrue. Choice (D) is another extreme that lacks evidence; later, he casually neglects Alice for present, temporary amusements.