PSAT Reading Question 39: Answer and Explanation

Question: 39

The position that Jay takes in this essay can best be described as that of

• A. an impartial onlooker pointing out both sides of an issue.
• B. a leader arguing for a particular outcome.
• C. an intellectual studying a historical decision.
• D. a spokesperson seeking a reasonable compromise.

Correct Answer: B

Explanation:

B

The question asks about the position that Jay (the author) takes in the essay. Since this is a general question, it should be answered after the specific questions. Over the course of the passage, Jay, a Founding Father, argues that the United States should not be split into smaller, separate nations. Eliminate answers that don't match this prediction. Choice (A) can be eliminated because Jay is definitely not an impartial onlooker pointing out both sides of an issue. Choice (B) matches the prediction, so keep it. Choice (C) can be eliminated because, for Jay, this is not a historical decision but rather a current event. Choice (D) can also be eliminated because Jay argues for a particular side in his essay. He is not looking for a compromise. The correct answer is (B).